Home Stock Analysis War in Ukraine: Part 2 – The New World
Read this article in Russian Russian

War in Ukraine: Part 2 – The New World

by Vitaliy Katsenelson
10 comments

Just as 9/11 dramatically changed the flow of history, resulting in two wars and hundreds of thousands of deaths and millions of lives ruined, so too will Putin’s invasion of Ukraine. Right now, we are seeing only the first effects and getting glimpses of second-order effects. The broad third-order effects will not be visible for a long time, though they’ll be obvious in hindsight.

War in Ukraine: Part 2 - The New World

If you’re interested, the list of Ukraine-focused charities is here.

This is part 2 of my series on the Russian invasion of Ukraine, you can read Part 1 here and Part 3 here.

At 4 AM on February 24th, the world changed. This was the 9/11 moment for Europe and much of the rest of the world. Just as 9/11 dramatically changed the flow of history, resulting in two wars and hundreds of thousands of deaths and millions of lives ruined, so too will Putin’s invasion of Ukraine. Right now, we are seeing only the first effects and getting glimpses of second-order effects. The broad third-order effects will not be visible for a long time, though they’ll be obvious in hindsight. 

On March 7, 1936, the German army violated the Treaty of Versailles and entered into the Rhineland. Here is what Hitler later said:

The forty-eight hours after the march into the Rhineland were the most nerve-racking in my life. If the French had then marched into the Rhineland, we would have had to withdraw with our tails between our legs, for the military resources at our disposal would have been wholly inadequate for even a moderate resistance.

Those two days determined what Germany would do next: build out its army and start World War II. 

Putin’s 1936 moment was in 2014 and 2015 when Russia invaded Crimea and Eastern Ukraine. (Some would argue it started earlier, in 2008, with the excursion into Georgia.) At the time, the West put toothless sanctions on Russia. Despite pleas from the US, the EU did not even consider increasing its defense budget. This inaction emboldened Putin to start his war with Ukraine. Today we are close to 1939, with Germany’s invasion of Poland and the start of what later became known as WWII. Except that it seems that Europe, acutely aware of its dark history, has finally woken up. 

A day or two after Russia invaded Ukraine, the US and European countries started to come out with sanctions. They were pathetic and laughable. The low point was when Italy excluded exports of Gucci bags to Russia. It seemed like 2014–2015 all over again, in line with what Putin was expecting.

Then something changed on February 26th

I don’t think it was just one factor but a confluence of events: 

  • The horrors of this war were broadcast on social media for the world to see. This time it was not happening far away but just a few countries over to people who looked just like most other European citizens. 
  • When Sweden and Finland declared in recent days that they were exploring joining NATO, Putin threatened them with political and military actions (war!). Let’s pause. I want you to process this for a second. Russia was threatening war with two other nations, neither of which had even been part of the Soviet Union, if they made decisions to determine their own fate. This time it did not feel like an empty threat.
  • Volodymyr Zelensky did not escape to Poland or to the US. In a rejoinder to the US’s offer of safe haven, he said, “I need weapons, not a ride.” He reenergized not just Ukraine but the rest of the world. (I wrote this article about this wonderful man when he was elected). The bravery of the Ukrainian people was and is inspiring. 

European countries suddenly woke up and realized that they might be next. 

As I have mentioned, this is the third (!) incursion by Russia into Ukraine. In the first one it chopped off Crimea, and then it invaded and destabilized the Donbass and Lugansk areas of Ukraine. These first two incursions were accomplished through lies. Just imagine this: Somehow Russian soldiers and tanks (yes, tanks!) ended up in Eastern Ukraine. Neither tanks nor soldiers were officially Russian. The soldiers were ex-Russian Army (though you did not have to have much imagination to understand that they were on the Russian payroll, which Putin of course denied). Crimea was invaded without a shot and “had a referendum”. 

Until now Europe had chosen to take Putin’s lies lying down. It could see through them, but the truth was inconvenient for anyone other than Ukraine. 

This time there were no pretenses. Putin has sent a good-sized chunk of the Russian Army into Ukraine. The Europeans realized that instead of fighting Russia with their own armies in the future, they could arm and support Ukraine today. 

A dictator’s thirst for power is insatiable. After Russia swallowed Ukraine (with a lot of indigestion – more on that next) it would continue to try to put the Soviet Union back together, gobbling up other ex-Soviet republics. Europe could continue to ignore it and come out with more toothless sanctions, but at some point Putin would go after Estonia and Latvia, which are NATO countries. If NATO didn’t defend them, Europe as we know it would be over. 

Before February 25, Germany (insultingly) sent helmets to Ukraine. Today it is sending anti-tank weapons. The EU is providing hundreds of millions of dollars’ worth of weapons to militarily outmatched Ukraine. Today every country in Europe wants to outshine the next with its real, tangible support to Ukraine. 

European countries have closed their airspace to Russia (and the US just joined them). The West has frozen Russian Central Bank foreign reserves – I did not even know that was in anyone’s arsenal of sanctions. Many Russian banks have been removed from SWIFT, the foreign interbank payment system. Not all banks were cut off from SWIFT, because Germany and Italy rely heavily on Russian gas for their power generation. 

What is really amazing is that the corporate sector has joined the fight, too. Google Pay and Apple Pay no longer work in Russia. Apple has even stopped selling iPhones in Russia. Mastercard and VISA have blocked their networks in Russia. Soccer teams are cancelling their matches with Russian clubs. I did my little part: My next book was also going to be published in Russia. Now it will not, but I will be happy to see it published in Ukraine. 

Russia is being cancelled, excommunicated from modernity by the West. It is being treated as the pariah it is. 

I want to stress this point: Putin considers these post-February 26 sanctions which far exceed what he expected as declarations of war by the West against Russia. No, we don’t have the West’s armies on the ground in Ukraine, but the Russian Army is being fought with the planes and other weapons that are arriving nonstop to Ukraine from the West, and the Russian economy is being crippled by the West.

I fully support sanctions. Part of me is celebrating, and another part of me is sad. The Ukrainian people are not the only casualty of Putin’s war. The Russian people have suddenly found that they are facing a serious depression. I have read that a majority of the population supports this war and that Putin’s popularity is soaring. I am not sure I believe this – it is coming from media controlled by Putin. But even if it is true, these people are brainwashed and zombified by state-controlled media to a degree you cannot imagine. They have no sense of reality; they live in Putin’s Matrix. I’ll talk about that at length next time. 

Then What?

Putin did not just miscalculate the West’s response, he completely missed the Ukrainians’ will to fight. This is in part why I was utterly convinced the war would not happen. I wrote: 

I think Putin is bluffing – Russia doesn’t want a full-blown invasion of Ukraine. It would result in endless guerilla warfare in Ukraine. The Russian Army is superior to Ukraine’s, but there would be no victory in that war. Russia occupies Ukraine, and then what?

Then what? I vividly remember how Russians and Ukrainians and the rest of the Soviet Union fought the Nazis in WWII. I remember self-sacrifice. I grew up a block away from a statue of Anatoly Bredov, a Russian hero who blew himself up to keep the Nazis from reaching a strategic high point in 1944. Russia would not let me forget, and rightfully so. Statues of heroes who gave their lives while fighting Nazis are all over Russia. 

During WWII both Russians and Ukrainians displayed plenty of heroism, but they had the “why” – they were fighting Nazi Germany for their families, for the future of their kids, for their homeland. 

My thinking was, if Russia invades Ukraine to kill their democratically elected government and to install their own military puppet government and thus turn Ukraine into another, smaller version of dictatorial Russia, the Ukrainians will not stand for that. Ukraine is not a perfect democracy; it has its share of problems. But it is a democracy. It has things we in the West often take as much for granted as we do running water (I know I often do): freedom of speech, free elections, the rule of law, and due process. 

I knew Ukrainians would fight to preserve that. And that is exactly what they are doing today. Ukrainians are behaving the same way they did when they fought the Nazis. Here is just one example: The Ukrainian soldier Vitalii Skakun blew himself up detonating mines so Russian tanks couldn’t cross a vital bridge. (I am proud to share a first name with this hero!)

In a delusional act of self-deception (or just plain arrogance), Putin thought Ukrainians would throw a welcoming party for Russian tanks roaming through Kyiv. The Ukrainians threw him a party, but by tossing Molotov (Zelensky) cocktails at the tanks, fighting till their last breath. Tens of thousands of volunteers have enlisted in the Ukraine Army. Even Kharkiv, one of the most eastern cities in Ukraine, with a predominantly Russian population, is fighting the Russian Army with all its will. 

US General H. R. McMaster said, “To win a war you need both capability and will.” Ukrainians definitely have the will, and now they are getting the capability shipped to them from the West. Will it be in time?

The ineffectiveness of the Russian Army is somewhat surprising. But when you think about it, maybe it shouldn’t be. Russian soldiers don’t have the will – the “why.” What are they fighting for? Putin? Even if they believed in the “ridding Ukraine of neo Nazis” nonsense (I’ll address this topic in the future), their families were not threatened by Ukraine. Many have friends and family in Ukraine. They are them. I have a hard time imagining Russian soldiers sacrificing their lives to invade Ukraine. 

This is why Russians soldiers are surrendering to Ukrainians. They are not cowards. I watched a dozen short video interviews with captured Russian soldiers. Their stories were one and the same. They were on training exercises. They were told they were going on a peace-keeping mission to Donbass and Lugansk. They crossed the Ukrainian border but found they were going to Kyiv or Kharkiv instead. I’d argue that these soldiers who surrendered are heroes. Unless there is a regime change in Russia, they cannot ever go back to Russia or they’ll be imprisoned for 15 years as deserters.  

I know the Russian soldiers who are dying will not get much sympathy from us, after we have watched Ukrainian cities being demolished by Russian artillery. But these are just 18-year-old kids who were conscripted into the army. Even the ones that signed up voluntarily did not know that they’d be facing their Ukrainian brothers. These young soldiers who have been killed have parents and siblings who just lost their loved ones. I am maybe extra sensitive because I have a 20-year-old son who has been taught to love, not hate. He was born in the US. But he could have been born in Russia if my family had not been lucky enough to move to the US in 1991. I also remember being 18 years old in Russia and terrified that I might be drafted into the Russian Army. (I wrote about that experience here.)

The Russian Army is also not as capable as we feared. It is handicapped by kleptocracy. A lot of Russian tanks have been gutted, the metals from them sold for scrap and the instruments are taken out and sold on the black market. I am not surprised. Some things haven’t changed over the decades since I left Russia. 

Also, just like any dictator, Putin staffs people in key positions based not on their capability but on their loyalty to him. Take the Russian Minister of Defense. Unlike in the US, where the Secretary of Defense is a political not a military position, in Russia the Minister of Defense is also a general in the army. Notably, the current Minister of Defense, despite being a general in the army, has no military background. None. 

This is why I am so optimistic and worried at the same time. Ukrainians have the will and an increasing capability. The Russian Army has no will and the army is somewhat sclerotic. I am worried because, in place of tanks rotting on Ukrainian roads, either abandoned or out of gas, Putin will start using heavy artillery and missiles to level these cities. We already started seeing that on March 1st. But this war is not winnable for Putin even if he invades every major city. The Ukrainians will keep fighting and the West will keep supporting them. 

Just to clarify, my main occupation is value investing and I did not become a rear admiral and military expert overnight. Please take what I just wrote with a grain of salt – I certainly do. 

The World Has Changed

Ironically, before Putin started this war, the NATO that was “encroaching” on Russian borders was a toothless one. It was in semi-retirement and collecting peace dividends from the Cold War. The Ukrainian invasion brought it out of retirement. Today we see the NATO that existed during the Cold War, the one that Putin should fear. The peace dividend got cancelled by Putin (together with coupon payments on Russian bonds held by foreigners). European defense budgets are going up. Germany is boosting its defense spending by more than 30%. Other European countries will follow. NATO is more united than ever before. It now has a clear objective, which it did not have for over three decades. 

China is paying close attention to what is going on in Ukraine, and it probably doesn’t like what it sees: a stronger, more coordinated West. Europe finally awakened to its dependence on natural gas from Russia. Even if the war ends tomorrow, Europe is on an irreversible course to reduce its reliance on Russian gas. Unfortunately, Germany is doubling down on green energy and coal instead of going back to nuclear. (I wrote on this topic here.) 

As Russia has been cut off from the rest of the world in everything from planes to smartphones, it has been pushed into Chinese hands. Russia has what China needs – commodities. Before the Olympics Russia signed a large deal to sell its natural gas to China. China in turn will likely be providing Russia with everything the West is depriving it of. 

The newly invigorated NATO and the extent to which the West has slapped sanctions on Russia make a Taiwan invasion by China – which would have a much greater impact on the global economy than the Ukraine invasion – less likely now. This topic requires a lot more thinking and analysis because China is economically much stronger than Russia and our dependence on China is much greater. Apple, for instance, cannot stop shipping iPhones to China if it invades Taiwan, not just because China is one of its largest markets, but because almost all of its iPhones are made in China. But it is a given that, just like the pandemic (which Putin made us forget about), the Ukraine war has reinforced and accelerated the movement toward deglobalization. 

Next: In part 3 I will discuss the future of Russia.[/signinlocker]

10 comments

sam3 March 3, 2022 - 3:21 pm

Two additional charities: http://makompioneers.org.il/ – MAKOM is working with the Jewish Agency to assist Ukrainian refugees in general, and Jewish refugees to make Aliyah. Here’s a JNS piece about their work: https://www.jns.org/wire/jewish-national-fund-usas-makom-communities-support-jews-on-the-ukrainian-border/

Nephesh B’Nephesh – https://www.nbn.org.il/ – is also assisting new immigrants from Ukraine. Those travelling to Israel may contact NBN to learn what toys, clothes, supplies etc. they might bring with them to donate to new Olim from Ukraine.

Reply
kimyongng March 3, 2022 - 6:53 pm

Thank you. This is a really interesting article.

Reply
lee2253 March 4, 2022 - 5:56 am

Good explanation of the situation. Thanks.

Reply
rdavies666 March 5, 2022 - 8:26 am

Hi Vitaliy, thanks for your excellent article.
I have a question which perhaps you can consider at some point. I also was certain that Putin would not be so foolhardy as to launch a full-scale invasion of Ukraine. But, you say, “In a delusional act of self-deception (or just plain arrogance), Putin thought Ukrainians would throw a welcoming party for Russian tanks roaming through Kyiv”.
My question is, why would he think this? Everything I hear about Putin indicates that he’s a student of history, therefore, I assume that he realised the points that you make about the likelihood of Ukranians’ propensity to defend their homeland, given the WW2 experiences that you describe.
It makes no sense to me, unless we think about the frequently made assertion that Putin doesn’t care for the Russian people, Putin only cares about Putin. If that’s the case (and I think the evidence is clear), then Putin cares even less for Ukrainians, and is prepared to annihilate the population. This becomes merely a grab of territory, which will later be repopulated by Russian nationals. It’s a depressing scenario,
I’m just an ordinary guy, living in the UK, with little knowledge of history, or global politics. But, all I can do is try to work out the logical consequences of the situation as is being discussed. I’d be very happy to be corrected. The key point for me is to understand the likely consequences of the West taking a more aggressive stance in defending Ukraine, risking an escalation of the conflict beyond Ukraine’s borders. I have no doubt that morally, we should intervene, we should help (militarily). But the risk of escalation is unthinkable. As is the consequence of leaving the Ukranian people to their fate.
Thank you.

Reply
Michael.Bade March 7, 2022 - 4:17 pm

Thank you, Vitaliy – I’m learning a lot from these articles. One form of charities individual people I know have started doing doesn’t result in tax savings for the donor, but has a big beneficial effect. This is to pay for AirBNB rentals in Ukrainian cities and tell the host you are not going to use the apartment. Most are filled with refugees, anyway, and by paying for the rentals one is helping the refugees. I haven’t learned whether social service agencies are also doing this.

Reply
alhitch52 March 7, 2022 - 5:10 pm

Great read. Thank you.

Reply
pj48north March 7, 2022 - 7:27 pm

“But even if it is true, these people are brainwashed and zombified by state-controlled media to a degree you cannot imagine. They have no sense of reality; they live in Putin’s Matrix.”

Adjust a few words here and there, and it sounds frighteningly similar to our situation here in DJT’s ‘Merica. For the first time in my life, I’m truly afraid for my own homeland.

Reply
Lloyd Forester March 8, 2022 - 8:03 pm

It saddens me that we do not have a universal draft.

Fathers want freedom and democracy but they do not want to pay the price.

Reply
farida1mistry March 13, 2022 - 11:04 am

The future of Russia is North Korea. Who are the best chess players in the world? Russians. How did we all underestimate Putin. He is a smart chess player. He has his troops surrounding two nuclear power plants in Ukraine. Thats his move, What is the EU and US going to do now. He is not afraid to die and he will take millions of souls with him. He just put us in a global ression the likes of the great depression 100 years ago. It is too bad Hell is empty and all the devils are here.

Reply
David Foster March 23, 2022 - 10:40 am

Vitaliy, great essays!…but what happened with Parts 3 and 4? I got Part 3 in email, but not on the website.

Reply

Leave a Comment

You may also like

[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]